Tuesday, December 10, 2013

CAUSES OF THE GREAT DEPRESSION

        Many historians have mixed views on the causes of the great depression and what specific events led up to it. Mr. Stewart told us about how the first market crash was huge and hit everyone hard and gave most people a surprise, but was not when the Great Depression started. He referred to this as the sneeze inferring that there had been a "virus" or a true cause that had been implanted and growing throughout the years prior to the first crash. As you know the market continued to fall for years which makes it safe to say it took quite a long time to build up to such an extended level as well. Basic answers for the causes are bank failures and the stock market crash, but what is interesting is that the causes of those things are what are ultimately set up our economy for failure.

       The deeper causes that probably added to the instability of the market were probably general overproduction and lack of reliable international trade which Mr. Stewart also touched on. Overproduction is a direct cause of the effect of unemployment and the lack of need for workers when the supply is so high and the demand gradually lowering. International trade had gotten significantly more complicated since the end of World War 1. After Germany was forced to pay for all the war costs through reparations they needed to borrow large amounts of money in order to rebuild their industry which would allow them to eventually pay the allies back on their own. Meanwhile, the allies used the money from Germany to pay the U.S. for all the weapons and supplies we had given them during the war which created a circle of trade. Obviously this is not the most stable system because it relies on many aspects to work flawlessly including Germany to quickly rebuild all their country with such little money for the average person. This circle had a few critical holes in it which hurt international trade to an extreme amount.

5 comments:

  1. I don't think overproduction probably added to the instability of the market, I think it DID, because so many people lost their jobs, causing a 25% unemployment rate. The owners of big companies tried to keep their profit constant, even with the lowering demand of goods. They did this by laying off workers, minimizing their labor costs, and this then was equal to the amount of money they received from selling a lower amount of products.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If "lack of reliable international trade" was a major problem, are you saying that the Great Depression originated outside of the U.S.?

    p.s. I'm about 101% sure that WWII happened after the Great Depression (;

    ReplyDelete
  3. @Jenna Haha yea thanks for the added reasons, I agree.

    @Brandon I'm not saying it was completely caused outside the U.S., but I do believe that there were definitely a few things that other nations had done that helped lead to the disaster. Haha sorry for the typo I edited it to WW1.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Jenna and Brandon. Overproduction and international trade definitely contributed to the depression, but i don't think they were the main causes. The initial drop in consumer demand, leading to lay offs and the stock market crash started the economy on a downward trend it just couldn't recover from. I don't think there is one main "cause" for the depression. I think it was a collective of issues with our economy that all amplified each other.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that one major reason for the crash of the stock market was hiding of important information by powerful people in the stock market. A great point was made in my Freedom from Fear chapter that basically said since the stock market was a new thing in the 1920s, people did not research their stocks at all, and basically did whatever the important people in the stock market told them to do. There were also no laws that required companies to publicize information, so they only let out what they wanted. This lack of publicity in the stock market led to stocks looking like they were worth more than they actually should have been, and when people realized these stocks were not actually worth as much as the stock market said they were, the market crashed.

    ReplyDelete